The lure of temptation and history as novel

I’ve been reading Hamish Clayton’s novel Wulf, which Penguin published last year. It’s his first novel, and a few weeks back won the New Zealand Society of Authors award for best first novel of 2012. I can see why. Fantastic stuff.

The story pivots – creatively – around a real episode in New Zealand’s history; the notorious Elizabeth affair. Back in 1830, Captain John Stewart was persuaded by the chief Te Rauparaha (Clayton’s ‘Wulf’) to carry a war party south to the Akaroa peninsula. Stewart and his crew were complicit in the atrocities that followed, including what by British law was kidnapping, murder and cannibalism.

Clayton’s fictional version is unashamedly literature, formed as a Saxon epic poem. It is not ‘history’ in a literal sense. People of 1830 didn’t talk and behave as he portrayed them. His lead character is soulful, poetic, intellectual – the antithesis of rough sailors of the day. Clayton’s words speak to modern values, styles – the very things that make the book such great literature; he offers an epic, haunting experience for the twenty-first century reader.

And I think all of this enhances – not diminishes – the value of the book as a voice commenting on our history.

Let me explain. I’ve written the factual story of the Elizabeth affair into several of my non-fiction books – most recently Convicts: New Zealand’s Hidden Criminal Past, where I devoted half a chapter to it. And there is one curious fact – every source varies in the details. Sometimes opposing each other.

That has been the story for me – the fact that it has come down in versions, that we cannot reduce the tale to a coherent list. I devoted a chunk of that chapter in Convicts to the differences. But it doesn’t mean the truths of what happened are a mystery – quite the opposite. All the evidence, however much it collides in detail, points to a single coherent truth. We get a clear picture of the dissonance between British and Maori values, the strictness with which Maori adhered to Maori protocols – and the disgraceful way the British captain and his sailors disregarded British ones.

This is what history is really all about – events whose meaning highlight the human condition. I approached it one way in Convicts. Clayton has done so in a completely different way in Wulf. Allegory and metaphor – all the art of writing, in short – still conveys the real truth about what happened when people of one culture were removed from the frameworks that constrained them and fell to the lure of what was forbidden to them in their own world.

It’s not just a New Zealand historical thing. It’s called succumbing to temptation.

Copyright © Matthew Wright 2012

2 comments on “The lure of temptation and history as novel

  1. Lemuel says:

    Great post! I look forward to reading your chapter on the Elizabeth incident and Hamish Clayton’s book is also on my to-read-list.

    As a South Islander I grew up with fond memories of holidays at Akaroa. I still remember reading an account of the Elizabeth incident and the other local musket wars history for the first time and being absolutely gobsmacked that such events took place in that idyllic harbour. I still love Akaroa, but once you learn about those episodes in its history you can never look at it the same way again.

    • Thanks. It was one of those incidents that made the pre-colonial pakeha era so colourful. There were others of similar calibre, but this was the one that caught the headlines in Sydney and has rather gone down in legend. I always figure Captain Harwood was worse; he took Ngati Mutunga to the Chathams in 1835, where they proceeded to massacre the Moriori. Harwood always claimed he had been hijacked, but that didn’t explain why he made two trips.

Join the discussion!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s